A Study on HRD Culture and Climate and
Their Impact on Employees Performance at Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL)
Dr. Usha Tiwari
Faculty, Study Centre for HRD, A.P.S. University, Rewa (M.P.) India – 486 003
*Corresponding Author E-mail: skandbt@gmail.com
Organisational climate is a set of
characteristics of an organisation which are referred
in the description employees make of the policies, practices and conditions
which exist in the working environment. An organisation
become dynamic and growth -oriented if their people are dynamic and proactive.
Strong culture has almost considered as a driven force to improve the
performance of the employees. It
enhances self confidence and commitment of employees and reduce job stress and
improve the ethical behavior of the employees. Organisational
culture has a positive impact on the employee's job performance.
The present paper is an attempt
made to study the HRD culture and climate and their impact on employee
performance at Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL).
The study shows the HRD culture
and climate and their impact on employees performance to be good in Bharat
Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL). The average mean and percentage scores of the
overall 16 items have been computed at 3.643 (66.075).
KEY WORDS: HRD Culture, HRD Climate, Organisational Climate, Employees Performance, BSNL
INTRODUCTION:
Organisational
climate is a set of characteristics of an organisation
which are referred in the descriptions employees make of the policies,
practices and conditions which exist in the working environment An organisation become dynamic and growth oriented if their
people are dynamic and pro-active. The characteristics of organisation
HRD climate are : individual initiative, risk tolerance, direction,
integration, management support, control, identity, reward system conflict
tolerance, communication patterns.
Organisation
now are facing greater their challenges to retain their talented and competent
personnel with them. Thus, talent management has become the critical goal of HR
professionals. Among many others, improving the quality of HRD is reported to
be one effective alternative to face these challenges. A productive and
supportive environment is essential for effective learning and development in organisations.
This environment requires a
culture of collaboration and team spirit, top management's commitment towards
HRD initiatives and the effective implementation of various HRD sub systems.
Organisation's
norms and values have a strong affect on all of those who are attached with the
organisation. It is considered that norms are
invisible but if the organisation want to improve the
performance of the employees and profitability, norms are places first to look.
Strong culture has almost
considered as a driven force to improve the performance of the employees. It enhances self confidence
and commitment of employees and reduce job stress and improve the ethical
behaviour of the employees (Saffold, 1998). Organisational culture has a positive impact on the
employee's job performance. Organisation success
shows high return on equity and this become possible due to establishment of
good employees performance management system.
The present paper is an attempt
made to study the HRD culture and climate and their impact on employee
performance at Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL).
OBJECTIVES
OF THE STUDY:
i). To analyses the overall work culture of the organisation.
ii). To study the satisfaction level of the employees at personnel,
interpersonal and organisational level.
iii). To measure the effectiveness of communication system and other work
process.
iv). To study employees attitude towards their direct supervisor and
senior management.
v). To study employees attitude towards providing services to their
external customer.
HYPOTHESIS:
The main hypothesis of study is
follows -
(i) There is a significant relationship between
HRD culture and climate and organisutional
effectiveness.
(ii) HRD culture and climate is the most important instrument behind
every success and failure of any organisation.
(iii) HRD climate help to boost employee
morale, motivated and competent employees.
REVIEW OF
LITERATURE:
George and Ronald (1993) studies
how an organisations culture affects organsiational performance. Organisational
culture is operationalized by several latent variables i.e. organisational structure and purpose, organisational
value, task organisation, climate and individual
values and beliefs. These variables, inturn are
hypothesized to affect oranisational performance. It
appears that the comparison of visible aspects of culture across and within organisations can provide useful information for guiding
the directions of organisations.
By investigating the variables it may eventually be possible to explain why
some organisation are not performing as desired
levels of productivity.
Krik
et al (2001) studies the degree to
which organisational climate mediates the
relationship between human resource practices and customer satisfaction. The result indicates the
indirect effects of HR practices on customer
satisfaction were significant and relatively large while the direct
effect was nonsignificant. The results were
supportive of a social context model of the impact of human resource practices
on organizational out comes.
Babakus
(2003) suggested that top management commitment
to service quality, as manifested by frontline employees appraisal of
training. empowerment and reward, has a significant effect on their perceptions
of service recovery performance. The influence of management commitment to
service quality on service recovery performance is mediated by frontline
employees affective commitments to their organisation
and job satisfaction.
Chan et. al. (2004) tested
the direct and interactive effects of high performance human resource (HPHR)
practices and organisational culture on firm
performance. Although the HPHR practices were not an important influence on
performance. Result indicate that organiszational
culture can be a valuable resources for companies.
Colin (2004) suggested that
person- organitisation (P-O) fit is a key element in
both the level of job satisfaction and also in their level of organisational commitment whether measured by an instrument
or turnover rates. Organizational culture plays an important role in the level of job satisfaction and commitment in
an organisation. Result indicate that a bureaucratic organisational culture resulted the lowest level, an
innovative culture was next highest and a supportive culture had the highest
level of employee job satisfaction and organisational
commitment.
Lee (2004) investigate the
possible relationship between corporate culture and organisation
performance among Singaporean companies. Study has demonstrated the power of
culture influencing organsiational performance. For
study the organisational culture profile was used as
the primary research instrument.
Chenhall
(2005) said that the strategic performance measurement system (SPMS) provide a
way to translate and measure the both financial and non financial performance.
He also suggests that it is the incorporative nature of this measurement
technique; provides the potential to increase the strategic competitiveness of
the organisation.
Garry and Ivery
(2006) examines relationship between human resource management (HRM), work
climate, and organisational performance in the branch
network of a retail bank. The result show that the correlations between climate
and performance cannot be explained by their common dependence on HRM factors,
and that the data are consistent with a mediation model in which the effects of
HRM practices on business performance are partially mediated by work climate.
According to Bruce et. al.
(2009) the relationship between
favorable organisational climate and employee
turnover to be negative but the relationship between organsiational
climate and customer satisfaction and financial performance to be positive.
Hartnell
et. al. (2011) indicate that clan, adhocracy and market cultures are
differentially and positively associated with the effectiveness criteria. The
finding provide mixed support for the competing values framework (CVF's) nomological validity and fail to support aspects of the
CVF's proposed internal structure.
Shahzad
et. al. (2012) suggested that organisational
culture has deep impact on the variety of organisations
process, employees and its performance. Research shows that if employee are
committed and having the same norms and value as per organisation
have, can increase the performance toward achieving the overall organisation goals. Managers and leaders are recommended to
develop the strong culture in the organsiation to
improve the overall performance of the employees and organsiations.
Table 1- Item wise mean scores,
percentage scores and categories of HRD culture of climate and their impact on
employee performance at BSNL
|
S.N. |
Items/Factors |
Mean score |
% score |
CAG |
|
1. |
Organisation
culture/climate effect work
performance . |
3.35 |
58.75 |
Average |
|
2. |
Managers praise our performance. |
3.70 |
67.50 |
Good |
|
3. |
Communication system of organisation is good. |
3.50 |
62.50 |
Good |
|
4. |
Criteria for promotion is
performance basis. |
3.30 |
57.50 |
Average |
|
5. |
Management encourage the
employee to take initiatives. |
3.80 |
70.00 |
Fairly Good |
|
6. |
We enjoy team work in our
department |
4.20 |
80.00 |
Very good |
|
7. |
When senior delegates authority
to juniors, they use it as an opportunity
to development |
3.60 |
65.00 |
Good |
|
8. |
Better job security and carrier
growth make be retain with BSNL |
4.0 |
75.00 |
Fairly good |
|
9. |
People trust each other in organisation |
3.80 |
70.00 |
Fairly good |
|
10. |
Team spirit is of high order in
this organisation |
3.85 |
71.25 |
Fairly good |
|
11. |
The top management goes out of
way to make sure that employees enjoy their work |
3.45 |
61.25 |
Good |
|
12. |
The personnel policies in this organisation facilitate employee development |
3.90 |
72.50 |
Fairly Good |
|
13. |
People in this organsisation are helpful to each other. |
3.55 |
63.75 |
Good |
|
14. |
Employee are encouraged to
experiment with new methods and try out creative ideas. |
3.30 |
57.5 |
Average |
|
15. |
The top management believes that
human resources are an extremely important |
3.65 |
66.25 |
Good |
|
16. |
Promotion decisions are based on
the suitability of the promotion than on favoritism. |
3.35 |
58.75 |
Average |
|
|
Over all |
3.643 |
66.075 |
Good |
Categories :
P = Poor, AV = Average, G = Good, FG, Fairy Good, VG =
Very Good
Source - Primary Data
Figure - 1 Item wise and overall
average, percentage scores and categories of HRD culture of climate and their
impact on employee performance at BSNL
METHODOLOGY:
With a view to analyse
the HRD culture and climate and their impact on employees performance at BSNL,
16 items close ended structured questionnaires were distributed among various
cadres of employees. Interview and discuasion with
some employees was another tool for study. Secondary data collected from the
past literature, annual reports, data maintained by the BSNL was also
incorporated. The study was conducted in various offices of Rewa
and Satna divisions. The scoring was simplified in
percentage as per the formaula of Rao
(1991) i.e.
Percentage Score = Mean Score -
1x25
Five categories of gradation were
very good, fairly good, good, average and poor.
Table
:2 Category wise items of HRD climate and culture and its impact on employee
performance at BSNL
|
S.N. |
Category |
%
Range |
No
of Item |
Total |
|
1. |
Very Good |
80-100% |
6 |
01 |
|
2. |
Fairly Good |
70-80% |
5,8,9,10,12 |
05 |
|
3. |
Good |
60-70% |
2,3,7,11,13,15 |
06 |
|
4. |
Average |
50-60% |
1,4,14,16 |
04 |
|
5. |
Poor |
0-50% |
- |
Nil |
RESULT:
The Tables 1 and 2 and Fig. -1
under reference show the item wise mean score percentage score and category of
the 16 items obtained during survey in the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL).
Some of the trends notice are given below:
The HRD culture and climate and
their impact on employee performance appears to be good. The overall mean score
and percentage score of 16 items has been calculated at 3.643 (66.075).
The most important item
contributing very good score is (i) employee enjoy
team work in their department (item-6); other important factors resulting is
fairly good scores are (i) management encourage the
employee to take initiatives (item-5), (ii) better job security and career
growth make me retain with BSNL (item-8),(iii) people trust each other in organisation (item-9), (iv) team spirit is of high order in
this organisation (item-10), (v) The personnel
policies in this organisation facilitate employees
development (item- 12).
The items in which BSNL scored
good are - (i) management praise our performance
(item-2), (ii) communication system of organisation
is good (item-3) (iii) when seniors delegates authority to juniors, the juniors
use it as opportunity to development (item-7); (iv) the top management goes out
of way to make sure that employees enjoy their work (item-11), (v) people in
this organisation are helpful to each other
(item-13), the top management believes that human resources are an extremely
important and that they have to be treated more humanely (item-15).
The factors appears average scores
are (i) organisational
culture/climate effect my work performance (item-1), criteria for promotion is
performance basis (item-4), employees are encouraged to experiment with new
methods any try out creative ideas (item-14), promotion decisions are based on
the suitability of the promotion rather than on favoritism.
CONCLUSION:
On the basis of this study we can
concluded that HRD culture and climate has a positive impact on the employee's
job performance. Researcher shows that every individuals in the organisation has different culture and he/she first try to
adjust him with the norms and values of the organisation.
The adaptation of culture of the organisation is
helpful for the employees to done their work efficiently and effectively.
Performance of the employees caused for the increase in net profit of the organisation. Positive development is easier to achieve
when everyone is on a common path in the organisation.
Strong organisational culture is very helpful for the
new employees to adopt the organisational culture/climate
and to get the competitive advantage under particular conditions. Employee's
commitment and group efficiency plays very crucial role to adopt the values and
beliefs of the organisation and enhancing the
performance of the organisation.
SUGGESTIONS:
Based on the above observations
the suggestions which can be made at this juncture are:
(i) Authority should motivate their employees on
continuous basis.
(ii) Authority should try their best to create such an open environment
where in employees take initiative to show their work.
(iii) All the groups of employees should be subjected to integrated and
sound training policy.
(iv) Guiding spirit should be introduced.
(v) Personnel policy should be strengthened.
(vi) Authorities invest considerable time and other resources for ensure
development of employees.
(vii) Require more practical training for using the different apparatus
and machines.
(viii) Knowledge of various safety
promotional activity i.e. TQM, TPM, ISO certification norm awareness should be
given.
REFERENCE:
1. Babakus
Emin, Yavas Ugur and Turgav Avci O.M.K. (2003): The effect of management commitment to
service quality on employees affective and performance outcomes. Jour. of
Academy of Management Science Vol. 31(3) pp. 272-286.
2. Bruce
Cooil, Lerzan Aksoy, Timothy L.K. and Kiersten
M. Maryott (2009): The relationship of employee
perceptions of organisational climate to business
unit outcomes - An MPLS approach. Jour. of Service research Vol. 11 No.
03 pp.-277-294.
3. Chan
Lismen L.M., Shaffer M.A. and Snapel
(2004): In search of sustained competitive advantage : the impact of organisational culture, competitive strategy and human
resource management practices on firm performance. International Jour. of
Human Resource Management Vol. 15
(1) pp. 17-35.
4. Chenhall
R.H. (2005): Integrative strategic performance management system, strategic
alignment of manufacturing, learning and strategic outcomes an exploratory
study. Accounting Organisations and Society,
30 (5), 395-422.
5. Collin
Silvethorne (2004): The impact of organisational
culture and person - organisation fit on organisational commitment and job satisfaction in Taiwan. Leadership
and Organisation development Jour. Emerald group
pub. limited. Vol-25, (7).
6. emerging
market case studies . Emerald Group Pub. Limited.
7. Garry
A. Gelade and Ivery Mark
(2006): Management and work climate on organisational programme. Personnel
Psychology Vol. 56(2) pp. 383-404.
8. George
A.M. and Ronald H. Heck (1993): organisational
culture and performance : proposing and testing a model. Organisation
Science Vol.4 (2) pp..209-225.
9. Hertnell
Chad A., VU Amy yil, Kinicki
Angelo (2011) : Oganisational culture and Organisational effectiveness - A meta analytic
investigation. Jour. of Applied Psychology Vol. 96(4) pp 677-694.
10. Kirk
L. Rogg., David B. Schmidt, Carlashutt
and Neal Schmitt. (2001) : Human resource practices, organisational
climate and customer satisfaction. Jour. of management Vol. 27 (4) 431-449.
11. Lee
S.K.J. (2004): Carporate culture and organisational
performance.
12. Rao.
T.V. (1991): Readings in Human Resource Development. Oxford and IBH Pub. New Delhi.
13. Shahzad
F., Luqman R.A. and Khan A.R. (2012) : Impact of orgainisational culture on organisational
performance. Inter disciplinary Jour. of contemporary Research in Business
Vol. 3 (9) pp.975-985.
QUESTIONNAIRES:
1. Organization
culture/climate effect my work performance.
(a) Strongly Agree (b) Agree (c) Nether Agree Not
Disagree
(d) Disagree (e) Strongly Disagree
2. Managers
recognizes/praise our performance.
3. Communication
system of your organization is good/satisfactory
4. Criteria
for promotion is performance basis.
5. Management
of the company encourage the employee to take initiative.
6. We
enjoy team work in our group/department.
7. When
senior delegates authority to junior, the use it as an opportunity to
development.
8. Better
job security and career growth make me retain with BSNL.
9. People
trust each other in organization.
10. Team spirit is of high order in this organization.
11. The top management goes out of way to make sure that employees
enjoy their work.
12. The personnel policies in this organization facilitate employee
development
13. People in this organization are helpful to each other.
14. Employees are encouraged to experiment with new methods and try
out creative ideas.
15. The top management believes that human recourse are an extremely
important and that they have to be treated more humanely.
16. Promotion decisions are based on the suitability of the promote
rather than on favoritism.
Received on 21.01.2014 Modified on 25.04.2014
Accepted on 05.05.2014 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Management 5(3):
July-September, 2014 page 297-301